Esp32 40Msps oscilloscope project is closed and here is why.

Hi everybody, since my first post about the project I have made a couple video demonstrations and built several prototypes. I invested in the project a huge amount of time, but this is the time to admit that the project has failed. And I want to explain why.

The largest problem – incomplete unclear and misleading documentation of the esp32 chip. According to the specification, esp32’s I2S is able to work at 40MHz clock rate, but it’s not true (at least for parallel mode). According to my experiments and some information from other developers the maximum speed is 20MHz but even at this speed not all FIFO modes work. I have spent a couple of weeks investigating the problem and wondering why I2S at high speed puts 2 absolutely identical samples in the buffer. I found that other developers have the same problem and obviously it’s esp32 limitation.

The second problem – no JTAG debugging support. Unfortunately, I didn’t manage to make JTAG for esp32 work properly. Developers of “Sloeber IDE” did a greate job to create a fully functional IDE for Arduino platforms, but for some reasons, my j-Link doesn’t work with esp32’s OCD server from Espressif properly. When there is no proper documentation for the chip a proper debugger becomes a crucially important part of a successful development. But it’s not the case for esp32 (at least now, I hope in future it will be better).

The third problem – analog frontend of a high-speed oscilloscope is not a simple thing. Yes, my knowledge in analog electronics is relatively limited and it took me a while before I realized that I have underestimated the complexity of this part of the project. My goal was to create a very simple and cheap hardware that could be easily assembled by an amateur, but it seems to be not possible. Without shielding, bus drivers, operational amplifiers and other parts of a proper analog frontend it simply doesn’t work with proper quality. And when you put all of this in the project it becomes neither simple nor cheap.

So to summarize:

  1. My initial goals for the project (40Msps, low-cost and simple schematic) are not reachable with esp32 and selected hardware architecture. I think that 20Msps is a too slow speed.
  2. The development effort for esp32 is unacceptably high due to bad documentation and absence of proper debugging tools. But this statement is true only when you are doing something unusual. With typical tasks like web server hosting and wifi communication esp32 works well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s